Choose your location:
Sacha Inchi Oil vs Flax Seed Oil

The flax seed is one of the best known vegetables of high Omega 3 content; it is even superior to the Sacha Inchi content, according to the Study carried out by the "Universidad del País Vasco de España" and the "Universidad Agraria "La Molina" de Lima, Peru (please, look at the following chart).
NEVERTHELESS, THE SACHA INCHI OIL HAS ADVANTAGES IN RELATION TO THE FLAX SEED OIL FOR THE REASONS AND STUDIES REFERRED TO, AS SET OUT BELOW:
  • THE SACHA INCHI OIL IS HIGHLY DIGESTABLE, SUPERIOR TO THE FLAX SEED
  • THE SACHA INCHI OIL CONTAINTS NATURAL ANTIOXIDANTS LIKE THE ALPHA TOCOPHEROL AND BETA CAROTENE
  • THE SACHA INCHI OIL DOES NOT HAVE THE ANTINUTRIENTS THAT THE FLAX SEED OIL CONTAINS, WHICH PREVENTS ALSO THE ABSORPTION OF THE IRON IN THE HUMAN BODY.

Comparison Between Sacha Inchi Oil and Flax Seed Oil
NMR y FAME-GC Methods


Source: Universidad del País Vasco. Faculty of Pharmacy - 01006 Victoria. España.

Universidad Agraria La Molina, Lima, Perú.

H NMR: 1H Nuclear Magnetic Resonance

Fat vs Fats - Sacha Barrio Healey Nutrional Medicine / Complemented by Sacha Inchi

% Total Oil
%Linolenic Omega 3
% Linoleic Omega 6
% Olein
% Saturated Fat
a.
SI Cr1 (H NMR)
52.60
47.40
39.30
6.10
7.20
b.
SI Cr1 (FAME-GC)
48.50
51.50
34.50
8.90
5.00
c.
SI Cr2 (H NMR)
52.40
47.60
38.50
6.30
7.50
d.
SI Re (H NMR)
53.10
46.80
38.50
7.10
7.50
e.
SI Re (FAME-GC)
46.70
53.30
33.70
7.90
5.00
f.
SI Ref Hamaker
54.80
45.20
36.80
9.60
7.75
~ Cr Study
51.17
48.83
37.43
7.10
6.57
~ SI Cr
52.08
47.93
37.28
7.73
6.86
~ General
51.35
48.63
36.88
7.65
6.66
Sacha Inchi
Pluketenia Voluvilis L
Flax Seed
Linum Ussitatisimum
Carbohydrates
Protein
Total Oil
     Linoleic Acid O-6
     Oleic Acid
     Alpha linolenic Acid O-3
     Saturated fatty
 
 
29.0 %
26.0 %
54.0 %
35.0 %
polyinsaturated
36.8 % a 38.2 &
14.0 %
Monosatured
6.9 % a 9.6 %
45.2 % a 46.9 %
58.0 %
Satured
6.8 % a 7.7 %


Next, it will be presented the characterization of the amino-acids in the protein of diverse oleaginous seeds, in which the superior characteristic of the Sacha Inchi can be seen clearly in respect to the others, particularly to the flax seed.

Amino acids content in protein, of the principal oleagineous seeds

Amino Acids
Seeds
F A O
W H O
O N U 3
Sacha Inchi
Sunflower
Soya
Penut
Cotton
Flax Seed
Total Proteins.
29
24
28
23
23
26
-.-
ESSENTIALS AMINO ACIDS
Histidine
26
23
25
24
27
19
Isoleucine
50
43
45
34
33
c
28
Leucine
64
64
78
64
59
c
66
Lisine
43
36
54
35
44
b
58
Methionine
12
15
13
12
13
b
-.-
Cysteine
25
15
13
13
16
-.-
Methionine + cysteine
37
34
26
25
29
25
Phenylalanine
24
15
49
50
52
c
-.-
Tyrosine
55
19
31
39
29
-.-
Phenylalanine+tyrosine
79
54
80
89
81
53
Threonine
43
37
39
26
33
c
34
Triptophan
29
14
13
10
13
c
11
Valine
40
51
48
42
46
c
35
NON ESSENTIALS AMINO ACIDS
Alanine
36
42
43
39
41
Arginine
55
80
72
112
112
c
Asparagine
111
93
117
114
94
Glutamine
133
218
187
183
200
Glycine
118
54
42
56
42
Proline
48
45
55
44
38
Serine
64
43
51
48
44
TEAA*
411
332
408
349
365
TAA*
976
907
975
945
936
TEAA (% de TAA)
42
37
42
37
39

Source: Hamaker et al. 1992. Arkansas University, USA. Complemented with Sacha Inchi.

*TEAA: Total Essential Amino-acids

*TAA: Total Amino-acids

1. The values are indicated in miligramms of proteins.

2. Values for Soya bean, peanut, cotton and sunflower have been taken from Bowel y Hopkins (1985)

3. Recommended levels for pre-school aged children (2-5 years). Recently have been recommended to evaluate the quality of the protein diet for all groups, with the exception of the infants. (Consulant's Meetings). Union of Expert Consultants of the FAO/WHO 1990.

C = Contains; b = lower content; but the value is not available.


Finally, one refers to various authorized quotations to conclude the comparison:

  • The flax seed has been strongly questioned as far as the amount of factors that interferes in the normal development of people and animals. The flax seed is used essentially to manufacture industrial products such as coatings, floor coverings, paintings and varnishes.
  • The restriction in the use of the flax seed in the human and animal consumption is due mainly to the toxic presence of cyanoglycoside (linamarin) and to antagonistic factors of the B6 Vitamin (Vetter, 2000; Center for Alternative Plant and Animal Products, 1995; Stitt, 1989; Butler et al., 1965). Recent discoveries demonstrate that the low levels of Vitamin B6 in the blood are associated to an increasing risk of fatal cardio-coronary disease and apoplexy (American Heart Association, 1999). The homocysteine, a non protein substance, which produces sulfur amino acid and is not a normal diet component, increases when the folic acid and the vitamin B6 are inadequate (Herzlich et al., 1996; Selhub et al., 1996). The researchers believe, that when the corporal cells release excessive homocystine in the blood, the interior of the arterial walls becomes irritated, stimulating the formation of fat deposit-plates which adhere in the arterial walls (McBride, 1999). Today it is recognized, that a high concentration of homocystine in serum becomes a considerable high risk, besides the cardiovascular diseases and apoplexy (Malinow, 1996; Boushey et al,1995).
  • All the varieties of the flax seeds contain anti nutritional factors, including the new variety FP967, a genetically modified organism (GMO), that has a concentration of total cyanogenic compounds (linamarin, linustatinase, and total neolinustatinase ), which are not different to the traditional ones (Canadian Food Inspection Agency, 1998).
  • The human consumption of the flax seeds is prohibited in France and in Germany, Switzerland and Belgium it is used with limitations(Le Conseil d'Etat, 1973). In the United States, although the human consumption is not prohibited, it does not have the FDA approval. This signifies, that under those circumstances, if a company decides to include the flax seeds in the formulation of a nutritional product, it will be responsible for any harm that may be caused. (Vanderveen, 1986).
  • Recent research works in animals have warned on the negative action of the flax seeds during the pregnancy and the reproductive period. These effects have been attributed to the denominated diclycoside ecoisolariciresinol (SDG) compound (SDG), that trough the bacterial action, acts in the mammals as a estrogenic depressor or stimulant. The flax seed is known as the richest source of SGD and therefore it is recommended to take a special care when its consumption takes place during the pregnancy and lactation (Toug et al., 1998; Rickard y Thompson, 1998).
  • Due to the flax seeds availability (as industrial oil) and its relatively low price, there have been several attempts to use it in the animal feeds as a source of fatty acids omega 3, but without much success. Numerous scientific publications have demonstrated the negative effects caused by the flax seed's anti nutritional factor
2007-2012 UHTCO Corporation, Ontario, Canada. All Rights Reserved.